The brief but intense air confrontation between Pakistan and India on May 6 and 7 was closely observed by militaries worldwide. It provided a rare opportunity to evaluate advanced fighter jets, pilot training, and modern air defense systems in a real combat environment.
Statement by French Commander
Captain Uk Lowe, commander of the French Naval Air Base in northwestern France, confirmed in a media interview that Rafale jets failed not because of technical flaws but due to the lack of skill among Indian pilots. Lowe, who has flown Rafales for more than 25 years, praised the Pakistani Air Force’s organized and timely response, calling it decisive in the outcome.
Indo‑Pacific Conference Remarks
At the Indo‑Pacific Conference, Lowe clarified that Rafale jets were not defeated by Chinese technology but by Pakistan’s strong defense and tactical planning. He revealed that more than 140 fighter aircraft were airborne during the clash, making the situation complex, yet Pakistan managed it more effectively than India.
Indian Objections
An Indian delegate attempted to dismiss Lowe’s comments as propaganda, but the French commander continued, stressing that the Rafale’s radar system had functioned properly and that the real weakness lay in its operators.
Technical Assessment
Lowe emphasized that Rafales are capable of defeating Chinese aircraft in combat, but their effectiveness depends entirely on pilot training and decision‑making. He also noted India’s growing interest in acquiring a naval version of the Rafale, capable of carrier landings and nuclear deployment, a capability currently exclusive to the French Navy.
Global Significance
Defense experts say the Pakistan–India clash has become a case study for air strategy worldwide. The encounter tested aircraft performance, pilot skill, and missile systems in a real combat environment, offering lessons that will shape future military planning across the Indo‑Pacific region.